Showing posts with label Swing Trading. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Swing Trading. Show all posts

Thursday, November 12, 2026

The Williams Commercial Index (WILLCO) | Larry Williams

The Williams Commercial Index is Larry Williams' measure of commercial positioning for swing trades and for position trades. The Commercials are the producers, processors, and merchants who use futures to hedge their own business. WILLCO is derived from the weekly Commitments of Traders (COT) report. Since 1975, the US Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) publishes that report every Friday. The positions in it are the positions held on the preceding Tuesday. WILLCO does not say whether the Commercials are net long or net short in contracts. It says where this week's commercial position sits against their own last 26 weekly reports. A reading of 100 can occur while the Commercials are still net short. It means only that this week is the most bullish their position has been in those 26 weeks.
 
 Commercials versus total Open Interest.
 
The calculation has two steps. Commercial Longs minus Commercial Shorts is divided by total Open Interest (OI). That result is called R. Dividing by Open Interest puts a large market and a small market on the same footing. R can be negative. It is negative when the Commercials are net short. WILLCO then ranks this week's R against 26 weekly readings (t). Those readings are the current report and the 25 reports before it. No later report is used. The rank runs from 0 to 100. A reading of 100 means this week's R is the highest of those 26 weeks. A reading of 0 means it is the lowest. If the highest R and the lowest R are the same number, WILLCO is set to 50.

Weekly CFTC Legacy COT report, Futures Only.

The calculation uses three figures from the CFTC Legacy COT report, Futures Only. Those figures are Commercial Longs, Commercial Shorts, and total Open Interest. Each reading is placed on the Friday the report is released, normally at 3:30 p.m. Eastern Time. It is not placed on the Tuesday when the positions were counted. If a report is delayed or missing, the chart keeps the last published reading. It does not estimate the missing week, and it does not invent a number.
 
   High WILLCO = Low Price: Prepare to Buy | Low WILLCO = High Price: Prepare to Sell.

Eight Weekly WILLCO Charts: Equities, Metals, Energy, and Agriculture
Eight weekly updating WILLCO charts at the bottom of this blog cover equities, metals, energy, and agriculture: the S&P 500 (ES), Gold (GC), Crude Oil (CL), Soybeans (ZS), Chicago Wheat (ZW), Sugar (SB), Coffee (KC), and Cocoa (CC). 
 
The upper part of each chart shows weekly price bars for the front-month continuous contract. Those prices are not adjusted when one contract expires and the next one takes its place. A weekly bar uses the first session's open, the high and the low of the week, and the last session's close. The change from an expiring contract to the next one can leave a gap even though the market itself did not move. A break of the previous week's high or low that comes only from that gap should be treated with caution.

The lower part of each chart shows WILLCO on a fixed scale from 0 to 100. A green band marks 
80 to 100. A red band marks 0 to 20. A dotted line marks 50. Each chart shows the latest 69 weeks. The calculation also uses 26 earlier weekly reports. Those reports lie off the left side of the chart and are not drawn. During the week that is still open, the price bar is updated as new prices arrive. WILLCO stays on the last published reading until the next Friday.
  
High WILLCO = Low Price: Prepare to Buy | Low WILLCO = High Price: Prepare to Sell. 
Veteran traders, analysts and economists consider the Commercials (producers, processors, merchants, and hedgers) the true "Smart Money" because they have deep physical or fundamental insight into the underlying commodity and fade the retail and speculative trends at major market turns. However, Non-Commercial Traders (Large Speculators, Managed Money) are most commonly referred to as the "Smart Money" because they represent large Institutional Players, Hedge Funds, and Commodity Trading Advisors (CTAs) trading purely for financial profit.
Why WILLCO
A conventional COT index ranks the raw commercial net, which is Commercial Longs minus Commercial Shorts, and it usually ranks that net over a year or more. The index most charts call the COT Index does this over 156 weeks. WILLCO changes both parts. It divides the net by Open Interest, and it ranks that result over the last 26 weeks only. Dividing by Open Interest keeps a change in the size of the market from distorting the reading. A large market and a small market can then be read on the same scale from 0 to 100.

In the agricultural markets, the Commercials are often net short, because producers sell futures against the crop they grow. The raw net can therefore look bearish week after week, even in a week when the Commercials are buying part of those shorts back. WILLCO does not treat that standing net short as a sell signal. It records whether this week's position is more bullish, or more bearish, than the Commercials' own last 26 weeks. Speculators hold the other side of these same contracts. Their position is largely the mirror of the commercial position, so adding it does not supply a separate fact. Every market uses the same scale from 0 to 100. A reading still belongs to that market alone. An extreme in Wheat says nothing about Soybeans.
 
Trading Signals and Execution
Only the two extreme zones produce a signal.
► From 80 to 100, the Commercials' position is among the most bullish it has been in the last 26 weeks. This reading appears while the price is still low. The signal is to buy, or to cover shorts, and only after the price rises through the high of the previous week.
►From 0 to 20, the Commercials' position is among the most bearish it has been in the last 26 weeks. This reading appears while the price is still high. The signal is to sell, or to go short, and only after the price falls through the low of the previous week. 
►
From 20 to 80 there is no signal. A reading near 50 does not point up or down.
A high WILLCO does not mean the Commercials are net long, and a low WILLCO does not mean they are net short. A reading of 100 means this week's commercial net, relative to open interest, is the highest of those 26 weeks, even when that net is still short. A reading of 0 means it is the lowest of those 26 weeks, even when that net is still long. WILLCO supplies the condition. The price supplies the signal to act.

The buy comes when a reading of 80 or higher is followed by a rise through the high of the previous week. The sell, or the short, comes when a reading of 20 or lower is followed by a fall through the low of the previous week. There is no need to wait for WILLCO to turn down from a high reading, or to turn up from a low one. A fall from 95 to 85 is still inside 80 to 100, so the condition is still the buy.


The Commercials are often early. In Soybeans, WILLCO entered the zone from 80 to 100 in June, while the price was still about 1,050 to 1,100 cents a bushel, and the price later rose toward 1,350. WILLCO then entered the zone from 0 to 20 in September, near that high, and the price later fell toward 1,200. A gap that comes only from the change of contract should be treated with caution. A signal in one market is not a signal in another. A high reading is not an overbought condition to sell against, and a low reading is not an oversold condition to buy against. The upper extreme is the bullish condition. The lower extreme is the bearish condition.
 
Reference:

Tuesday, November 10, 2026

ES, NQ, and YM vs. the S&P 500, Nasdaq, and Dow McClellan Oscillators

Three widgets in the blog's right column plot the ES against the S&P 500 McClellan Oscillator, the NQ against the Nasdaq McClellan Oscillator, and the YM against the Dow Jones McClellan Oscillator. Data are updated and charted daily.


The McClellan Oscillator is one of the most useful instruments for examining the internal condition of an equity market. It measures something conventional price charts cannot reveal directly: whether an index's movement is supported by broad market participation or driven by a relatively small group of stocks, as reflected in advance–decline metrics. The widgets independently calculate these figures for the S&P 500, the Nasdaq 100, and the Dow 30 after the market close (ET) and plot breadth signals: 
bullish and bearish zero-line crossings, divergences, and breadth thrusts. Moving the grey dashed vertical sliders across the charts displays the corresponding metrics for each date in the tables below them.
 
See also:

Monday, October 26, 2026

S&P 500 November Seasonality in Midterm Election Years

S&P 500 Cycle Composite for November 2026 (equal weight on One-Year Seasonal Cycle: 98 years; 
Four-Year Presidential Cycle — Midterm Year: 24 years; Decennial Cycle — years ending in 6: 9 years.).
 
Expect the S&P to rally from a late-October low into around Nov 11 (Wed), decline into
Nov 19–23 (Thu–Mon), then rebound into month-end. Direction matters more than level.
 
► November ranks 5th of 12 by average across all years (avg. +1.0%). 
● In Midterm Election Years it ranks 2nd (avg. +2.2%). 
● In the years ending in 6 it ranks 4th (avg. +1.4%).
● November was up in 61 of 98 years (62.24%, avg. +1.0%, med. +1.6%). 
● Midterm Election Year November was up in 21 of 24 (87.50%, avg. +2.0%, med. +2.2%).
► Nov 16 (Mon) through Nov 20 (Fri), expiration week, was up in 49 of 98 years (50.00%). 
● Midterm Election Years: 10 of 24 were up (41.67%, avg. −0.3%, med. −0.3%). 
 Q4 2026 Midterm Election Year Stretch.
► Oct 27 (Tue), 2026 opens the Midterm Election Year stretch that runs through Nov 10 (Tue), up in 20 of 24 Midterm Election Years (83.33%, avg. +2.3%, med. +3.1%). The misses were 1930, −11.2%; 1978, −2.7%; 1994, −1.6%; and 2002, −0.8%.
● Election day is Nov 3 (Tue). 
● The November piece, from the October close through Nov 10 (Tue), was up in 19 of 24 (79.17%, avg. +1.7%, med. +1.8%).
► Nov 26 (Thu) is Thanksgiving. The stock and bond markets are closed.
● From the session before through the Friday after, Nov 25 (Wed) to Nov 27 (Fri), was up in 72 of 97 years (74.23%, avg. +0.3%, med. +0.6%). The Friday was closed in 1929.
►  November through April the following year, from the October close to the April close, was up in 69 of 98 years (70.41%, avg. +5.2%, med. +5.4%).
 

S&P 500 is the best November seasonal short-term trade because Nov 24–Dec 6 has an R (profit divided by drawdown) of 1.54. It rose 1.89% on average from 2006 to 2025 and finished higher in 15 of 20 (75%) years. The average drawdown was 1.23%.
 

Nov 24–Dec 6 is a 9-session buy trade: From 2006 to 2025 the S&P 500 gained 1.89% and finished higher in 15 of 20 (75%) years. Through 2005 it gained 0.72% and finished higher in 51 of 78 (65.4%) years, and over the last 10 years it gained 1.08% in 7 of 10 (70%) years. The 2016–2025 average path ends +1.08% from the entry close by Dec 6, with up years averaging +2.74% and down years -0.66%. R is 1.54. The drawdown averaged 1.23% on the years that moved against the trade. The 2016–2025 average reaches +1.35% with 3 sessions still open and finishes +1.08%. That high in the small chart above is not a date, and a steeper piece of the line is not a better trade. The counted span is the close before Nov 24 through Dec 6.
 
 S&P 500 Detrended Presidential Cycle 2025-2028.
Correlation with the S&P 500 since January 1, 2026: -0.62. 
 
 Nasdaq.
 
 Dow Jones.
 
 Russell 2000. 

S&P 500: First Ten and Last Ten Sessions of the Month (Dec 30, 1927 - Dec 31, 2025).
 
S&P 500: Average Performance per Day & Day-by-Day Hit Rate (Jan 3, 1928 - Dec 31, 2025).

Monday, October 12, 2026

S&P 500 vs. Geomagnetic Ap Index and Kp Index

S&P 500 vs. Ap Index (May–Nov 2026).  Projected Ap Index Peaks (+4-Day Lag) = Expected S&P 500 Lows:
Oct 14 (Wed), Oct 17 (Sat), Oct 26 (Mon), Nov 4 (Wed), Nov 13 (Fri), Nov 22 (Sun).
The time it takes for a Coronal Mass Ejection (CME) to reach the Earth depends on several factors, such as the speed of the CME, the density of the solar wind, and the position of the Earth relative to the Sun. On average, a CME can take anywhere from about 15 hours to 6 days to reach the Earth: fast CMEs (speeds > 1000 km/s) 15 hours–2 days, average CMEs (speeds ~500–1000 km/s) 2–4 days, and slow CMEs (speeds < 500 km/s) 4–6 days.
Geomagnetic disturbances (elevated Ap index) are hypothesized to subtly impair collective mood and heighten risk aversion. Market participants may misattribute this psychological distress to economic fundamentals, leading elevated Ap to precede S&P 500 lows and trend reversals by a short lag of a few calendar days.

To evaluate this relationship, historical NOAA 45-day Ap forecasts (updated daily) were parsed into a continuous daily series using the most recent available issues. These values were correlated against daily S&P 500 close-to-close and absolute returns across 0 to +5 calendar-day lags from January 1, 2020, to present. Across the full sample, the 45-day forecast displays only modest directional correlation with next-day price movements; its primary statistical signal is a positive link to subsequent absolute returns (volatility), currently peaking around +4 to +5 days.

However, this optimal lag lacks long-term stability—holding near +4 days throughout the summer and early fall before shifting in recent windows—reflecting the limited predictive skill of multi-week geomagnetic forecasts. Comparative analysis shows that NOAA's 27-day Ap outlook provides neither stronger directional lead times nor greater stability than the 45-day series. Because the 27-day projection updates only weekly, its lower publication frequency introduces additional noise, making lead-lag relationships harder to measure than in the daily 45-day series.


The Ap Index (used in NOAA's 45- and 27-day forecasts) is the linear counterpart of the quasi-logarithmic Kp Index (used in NOAA's 3-day forecast). Each 3-hour Kp value converts to an equivalent amplitude via a fixed table (Kp 0→0, 1→3, 2→7, 3→15, 4→27, 5→48, 6→80, 7→140, 8→240, 9→400); the daily Ap is the average of those eight 3-hour values. The two indices therefore track the same geomagnetic activity on different scales.
 
NOAA's latest 3-day forecast above shows a peak Kp of 5 (equivalent Ap ≈ 48) on Tuesday, October 13, between 06:00 and 09:00 UTC (2:00–5:00 a.m. ET). Shifting that interval forward by three calendar days points to Friday, October 16; a four-day shift points to Saturday. This suggests another S&P 500 low may arrive by the end of the trading week.


To evaluate shorter-term dynamics, 180 days of NOAA 3-day Kp forecasts were compiled, converted to 3-hour equivalent Ap, adjusted to Eastern Time (ET), and exhaustively tested across lags of 0 to 120 hours against hourly S&P 500 closes to identify the shift with the strongest negative correlation to price level. The latest weekly charts above display hourly S&P 500 OHLC bars (left scale) overlaid with the 3-hour equivalent Ap series shifted forward by the optimal +45 hours on an inverted right scale. Each panel spans Saturday through the following Sunday to show the complete trading week in context.  
 
This optimal +45-hour lag differs from the +3 to +5 calendar-day lag observed on daily Ap charts because the NOAA 3-day forecast model (updated twice daily at 00:30 and 12:30 UTC; during EDT / UTC−4, this corresponds to 8:30 p.m. ET the previous day and 8:30 a.m. ET the same day) evaluates high-resolution, short-horizon Kp/Ap data against hourly prices over a shorter sample window, where forecast decay and short-term noise shift the best-fit alignment relative to multi-month realized daily Ap metrics.
 
See also:

Thursday, October 1, 2026

My Forecast for the Rest of 2026 | Larry Williams

US equities face near-term downside pressure and range-bound volatility amid poor breadth. Deteriorating internals—seen in the divergence between a strong NASDAQ, moderately strong S&P 500, and weak Dow and Russell 2000—suggest capital is rotating from quality blue chips into speculation, a pattern that has historically preceded broader sell-offs.


A major synchronized cyclical low and buying opportunity across the S&P 500, NASDAQ, Dow, and Russell is projected around Tuesday, October 27, ahead of the US presidential election. At the trough, focus capital on the index showing the strongest relative strength and greatest resistance to selling pressure during the decline.

Reference:
  
S&P 500 October Performance in Midterm Election Years.
Oct 27 (Tue) opens the midterm stretch that runs through Nov 10 (Tue), 2026, up in 22 of 24
midterm years (91.67%, avg. +2.6%, med. +3.2%). Misses: 1930 (−12.6%) and 1994 (−0.3%).  

 DJIA.

Russell 2000. 
 
 NASDAQ.
Detrended seasonal cycles isolate short-term periodic signals by removing longer-term trends, preventing distortion and enabling precise measurement of amplitude and timing.
See also:

Why the Best Part of the Presidential Cycle Starts Now | Jeff Hirsch

On the Full Signal podcast from October 1, 2026, Jeff Hirsch spoke about historical market cycles, midterm positioning, structural AI drivers, and actionable portfolio strategies.

Presidential Cycle 2025–2028: Midterm Sweet Spot expected rally target window: 
September 30, 2026 – July 19, 2027.
 
Presidential Cycles & The Midterm Sweet Spot
Midterm election years historically rank as the presidential cycle's weakest due to early-term policy friction and political uncertainty that drive a Q2–Q3 soft patch. By early October, markets transition into the cycle's most bullish window: the "midterm sweet spot" running from Q4 through pre-election Q2. Since 1949, this three-quarter stretch averages gains of +19% for the Dow, +20% for the S&P 500, and +29–30% for the Nasdaq, with midterm Octobers frequently marking the exact pivot bottom.

The AI Super Boom & Market Fundamentals
This cyclical tailwind merges with a secular "AI super boom" comparable to post-war industrialization or the early internet era. Driven by massive hyperscaler capital expenditure and robust semiconductor earnings, this fundamental expansion supports high valuations into 2027 and overrides traditional cyclical drags. Historical super booms prove that staying invested through temporary volatility is essential when liquidity and structural drivers hold, despite short-term risks from extreme mega-cap tech concentration.
 
 
Macro Strategy: Yields, Politics & Small Caps
Near 5% bond yields increase equity opportunity costs, but strong AI earnings power and presidential cycle tailwinds dominate asset allocation. Hirsch is rotating from fixed income into lagging small caps, which offer relative value, broadening market participation into 2027, and seasonal drivers like the January Effect. Preferred sectors include transports, selective industrials, stabilizing financials, and core AI infrastructure, while post-midterm political gridlock adds market-friendly policy stability.

Technical Timing & Seasonality Execution
Rather than relying on strict calendar dates, seasonal strategies require technical filters. For the "Best Six Months" strategy (November–April for broad markets; extended through June for Nasdaq), a confirmed positive MACD crossover on major averages on or after early October triggers the buy signal, while negative April/June crossovers signal exits. Institutional tax cycles, calendar flows, and psychology maintain seasonal edges, but MACD confirmation prevents false starts.
Jeff Hirsch uses MACD crossovers as a technical filter to execute the "Best Six Months" strategy. By combining technical momentum with the calendar, he avoids buying into falling markets or exiting strong spring rallies prematurely.
►
Timing Windows: The "Best Six Months" run Nov 1–Apr 30 for the Dow/S&P 500, extending through June for Nasdaq. Daily monitoring begins October 1 for buys and April 1 (June 1 for Nasdaq) for exits.   
► Indicator Setup: Daily charts with 12-day fast EMA, 26-day slow EMA, and a 9-day signal line.Buy Signal: On/after Oct 1, a positive MACD crossover (12-day EMA crosses above 26-day EMA) triggers the Seasonal Buy Signal, confirming downside momentum has ended before entering equities.
► Sell Signal: On/after Apr 1 (or Jun 1 for Nasdaq), a negative MACD crossover triggers the Seasonal Sell Signal, shifting exposure to cash or defensive sectors.
► Why It Works: It eliminates buying into October market crashes, captures extended spring upside, and reduces drawdowns compared to strict calendar dates or buy-and-hold strategies. 
Bearish Risks & Defensive Rules
Key risks to the base case include policy missteps, re-accelerating inflation, labor deterioration, geopolitical shocks, or an AI earnings reset. Shifting bearish entails tactical risk management—tightening stops and trimming laggards—rather than full liquidation, maintaining flexibility if macro trends or technicals break down.
 

See also:

Tuesday, September 29, 2026

S&P 500 October Seasonality in Midterm Election Years

S&P 500 Cycle Composite for October 2026 (equal weight on One-Year Seasonal Cycle: 98 years; 
Four-Year Presidential Cycle — Midterm Year: 24 years; Decennial Cycle — years ending in 6: 9 years.)
► October ranks 8th of 12 by average across all years (avg. +0.6%). July is best (avg. +1.7%) and September is worst (avg. −1.1%). In midterm years it ranks 1st (avg. +2.4%) and September is worst (avg. −1.5%). In the nine years ending in 6 it ranks 3rd (avg. +2.1%). March is best (avg. +3.1%) and September is worst (avg. −1.5%).
► October was up in 58 of 98 years (59.18%, avg. +0.6%, med. +1.1%). In midterm years, 16 of 24 were up (66.67%, avg. +2.4%, med. +2.5%). From the September close through Oct 15 (Thu), all years were up in 63 of 98 (64.29%, avg. +0.7%, med. +1.3%). Midterm years were up in 17 of 24 (70.83%, avg. +2.1%, med. +2.1%).
► Oct 12 (Mon) is Columbus Day. The stock market is open. The bond market is closed. It is the first session of expiration week, up in 54 of 98 years (55.10%, avg. +0.1%, med. +0.1%). In midterm years, 14 of 24 were up (58.33%, avg. +0.2%, med. +0.3%).
► Oct 12 (Mon) through Oct 16 (Fri), expiration week, was up in 59 of 98 years (60.20%, avg. flat, med. +0.5%). The average is flat because a few weeks were large losses. In midterm years, 16 of 24 were up (66.67%, avg. +0.5%, med. +0.6%). Oct 16 (Fri), expiration day, was up in 47 of 98 years (47.96%, avg. −0.1%, med. flat). Midterm expiration days were up in 12 of 24 (50.00%, avg. +0.1%, med. +0.1%).
► Oct 27 (Tue) opens the midterm stretch that runs through Nov 10 (Tue), 2026, up in 22 of 24 midterm years (91.67%, avg. +2.6%, med. +3.2%). The misses were 1930, −12.6%, and 1994, −0.3%. 
► Election day is Nov 3 (Tue), 2026. Oct 27 (Tue) through Oct 30 (Fri) alone was up in 15 of 24 years (62.50%, avg. +0.6%, med. +0.6%).
► May through October, which this month closes, was up in 65 of 98 years (66.33%, avg. +2.5%, med. +3.6%). In midterm years, 12 of 24 were up (50.00%, avg. −0.6%, med. +2.1%). The average is down because a few of those years were large losses. The median year was up.
► Last quarter Oct 3 (Sat), 9:25 a.m. EDT. New moon Oct 10 (Sat), 11:50 a.m. EDT. First quarter Oct 18 (Sun), 12:13 p.m. EDT. Full moon Oct 26 (Mon), 12:12 a.m. EDT. No solstice and no eclipse this month.
Since January 1, 2026, One-Year Seasonality — All Years has shown the strongest correlation with the S&P 500
(Seasonal +0.89 · Composite +0.64 · Presidential −0.59 · Decennial +0.46). Seasonal is the closest match.
 
One-Year Seasonality — All Years. 
 
Since January 1, 2026, One-Year Seasonality — All Years has shown the strongest correlation with the S&P 500
(Seasonal +0.89 · Composite +0.64 · Presidential −0.59 · Decennial +0.46). Seasonal is the closest match.
 
S&P 500 2026 Performance vs. Composite Cycle and Components.
 
The much talked about potential rise from September 30 (Wed), 2026 through July 19 (Mon), 2027.  
 
See also:

Wednesday, September 2, 2026

S&P 500 vs. Jupiter–Saturn Cycle: A Clock, Not a Crystal Ball

Derived mainly from M.A. Vukcevic's insights and solar-activity formula linking heliocentric Jupiter–Saturn sidereal orbits to model the sunspot cycle, the concept below uses a proprietary higher harmonics formula to project S&P 500 market swings.

S&P 500 vs. Jupiter–Saturn Cycle | H2 2026.
Over 90% of tradeable, high-amplitude waves develop in the 7 to 12-day window. 
  
Jupiter's sidereal period is ≈11.86 years, Saturn's ≈29.46 years, their synodic period ≈19.86 years, and the Jupiter–Saturn spring-tide period ≈9.93 years. These tidal frequencies bracket the ~11-year Schwabe sunspot cycle, while the Vukcevic and Scafetta formulas treat Jupiter–Saturn orbital geometry as a pacemaker of the solar dynamo. With no consistent polarity or directional bias for the S&P 500, the blue Jupiter–Saturn curve inflects within a 1-to-11.9-day window (median 7.0 days, mean 6.3), and swings ≥7 days are bisected (blue squares) to optimize short-term correlation.
 
S&P 500 vs. Jupiter–Saturn Cycle | H1 2026.
 
The Jupiter–Saturn curve is not a crystal ball and it will not say whether to buy or sell. It is a clock. Two slow planetary rhythms were folded into a single wavy line, then sped up so that what once took years now takes days. That line rises, falls, and bottoms out again and again.

S&P 500 vs. Jupiter–Saturn Cycle | H2 2025.
 
S&P 500 vs. Jupiter–Saturn Cycle | H1 2025.

Troughs hold the edge — ignoring the rest saves energy. Troughs are the only feature showing positive 
statistical skill (+3 points over random chance). Peaks and midpoints offer zero edge over a coin flip.

After matching it to years of S&P 500 prices, only one part of the clock is worth attention: the low points, the troughs. The test is blunt. Each blue mark is given three calendar days to sit near a real 2% swing in the daily highs and lows; the same test is then run on random dates, so the extra percentage is the only thing that counts as skill. Troughs clear that bar. Peaks do not. Midpoints, whether a swing is cut in half by time or by height, do not either.

 Troughs mark volatility, not directional certainty. Blue troughs lean slightly toward S&P swing lows (+3 points),
but cannot guarantee direction. Attempting to trade blue crests yields negative skill vs. baseline expectation.
 
Target multi-day windows over intraday precision. Maximum predictive edge (+3.3 to +3.4 points) centers on 2%–3%
swings over a 2 to 3-day window. Expecting immediate same-day triggers introduces unnecessary market noise.
 
Those extra three points are modest, and they still do not pick a side. The color of the line — up or down — does not mean the market will follow. A trough lining up with an S&P low beats chance by about three points; a trough lining up with an S&P high does not. A peak is no better at calling a high than a low. In other words, a trough can sit under a rally or a selloff. It is a date when a real swing is a little more likely to finish, not a forecast of direction.
 
S&P 500 vs. Jupiter–Saturn Cycle | H2 2024.
 
S&P 500 vs. Jupiter–Saturn Cycle | H1 2024.
 
Used that way, the method is simple. The next trough is read from the calendar, including Saturdays and Sundays; the formula does not pause for the weekend. 
 
Filter out the daily ripples to trade the 7–12 day cycle. Short cycles under 6 days represent market interference
with negligible height. Over 90% of meaningful amplitude occurs within the 7–12 day wave structure.

A short window opens around that date: two days before through three days after, which is the same band in which most of those 63% of hits actually land. If the trough falls on a weekend, the window runs from the Thursday before through the Wednesday after. Inside that window nothing is done until the S&P itself speaks. 
 
S&P 500 vs. Jupiter–Saturn Cycle | H2 2023.
 
S&P 500 vs. Jupiter–Saturn Cycle | H1 2023.
 
The wait is for price to carve a high and then drop at least two percent from that high, using the day’s actual high and low, not the close — that may be treated as a short, with risk defined just above the high. Or the wait is for price to carve a low and then rise at least two percent from that low — that may be treated as a long, with risk defined just under the low. Only the first such reversal is taken. If the window closes and neither has happened, there was no trade. The little wrinkles on the blue line are skipped as well: if the fall into a trough was tiny, it is interference, not a beat, and it can be ignored.

S&P 500 vs. Jupiter–Saturn Cycle | H2 2022.
 
S&P 500 vs. Jupiter–Saturn Cycle | H1 2022.

The position is left when it has paid twice what was risked, or when price completes a two-percent swing the other way, or when the next serious trough arrives. Then the wait begins again. A signal will not appear every week, and that is the point. A good year of this habit is a handful of attempts, not a lifestyle. Three extra points versus picking dates at random is not a license to force a trade; costs, hesitation, and the occasional late swing that lands a week off the mark can wipe the edge out.

S&P 500 vs. Jupiter–Saturn Cycle | H2 2021.

S&P 500 vs. Jupiter–Saturn Cycle | H1 2021.
 
S&P 500 vs. Jupiter–Saturn Cycle | H2 2020.

S&P 500 vs. Jupiter–Saturn Cycle | H1 2020.

What is being practiced is attention, not prediction. The market still has to print the turn in the window, in its own highs and lows, or there is no trade. Used that way, the curve earns a place on the desk: a reminder to look up for a few days, then to look away until the next low. 
 
Jupiter–Saturn Cycle | H1 2027.
 
 
See also:
Previous S&P 500 vs. Jupiter–Saturn Cycle examples [HERE].