Showing posts with label Toby Crabel. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Toby Crabel. Show all posts

Tuesday, November 17, 2026

George Taylor's Three-Day Market Cycle

George Douglass Taylor was a Chicago Board of Trade grain trader whose meticulous market records led him to formulate the three-day "Book Method," published in The Taylor Trading Technique in 1950. His contribution was a practical way to study recurring short-term market behavior, identify likely buying and selling phases, and organize daily price action—a framework that remains useful to short-term traders of futures and equities.
 
Idealized Taylor Three-Day Market Cycle: The Buy Day establishes a low and recovers; the following sessions test progressively higher reference points, with the Sell Short Day challenging the Sell Day high before retreating (bars are schematic, not historical market data).
The Three-Day Market Cycle
Taylor organized short-term market behavior into three recurring phases: the Buy Day, the Sell Day, and the Sell Short Day. The framework is intended to help a trader anticipate where buying or selling pressure may emerge, rather than simply react to each new price movement.

Taylor's notebook was a systematic analytical record of daily OHLC prices, successive rallies
and declines, intersession price relationships, and key buying and selling objectives.

The Buy Day is associated with a decline toward a potential low and a buying opportunity. The Sell Day follows, when a rally may offer an opportunity to sell or reduce a long position. The Sell Short Day is associated with a rally toward a potential high, where a short-selling opportunity may develop. The sequence then returns to the next Buy Day.
Buy Day: End of a decline (usually after 1–3 high-to-low days). Expect a test below the prior day's low that fails (excess low), then a rally. Buy the rejection of the prior low; hold for residual strength into the next day(s). Avoid if the low is accepted and price keeps falling.

Sell Day: Residual momentum day after the Buy Day. Expect price to work higher toward or through the prior day’s high as longs are liquidated. Scale out or exit longs into strength; do not initiate new longs late. Range or modest upside is normal.

Sell Short Day: End of a rally (mirror of Buy Day). Expect a test above the prior day's high that fails (excess high), then a decline. Short the rejection of the prior high; target the subsequent pullback. Avoid if the high is accepted and price keeps rising.  
The cycle is a market-timing framework, not a mechanical three-session forecast. Taylor's original method allows for variations, and the sequence may need to be suspended or reset when price action does not conform to expectations.
 
 » Very few people can blindly follow a system. Many find it easier to be discretionary in a systematic way. «
 
 Day 1: Frontside: Luring traders onto the "escalator." Day 2: Peak formation: The final trap. 
Day 3 / Day 1: Consolidation: The pressure builds. Day 2: Backside rapid descent.
Classic Pump-Coil-and-Dump pattern. The inverse pattern is: Dump-Coil-and-Pump.
The Stacey Burke way to trade the Taylor Cycle.
 
The Importance of the Intraday High-Low Sequence
Taylor did not record only each day's high, low, open, and close. He also noted whether the day's high or low occurred first. This distinction matters because two sessions can produce identical OHLC values but follow very different intraday paths. 
 
Intraday Sequencing within the Three-Day Cycle. The ideal Buy Day makes its low first and then recovers. On Sell Days and Sell Short Days, Taylor tracked whether the high occurred early or late, comparing the observed sequence with the expected behavior of that phase. The timelines are explanatory schematics, not fixed intraday rules.
In Taylor's notation, the order of the high or low was part of the record, not a decorative detail. When the expected sequence failed to appear, he could adjust the cycle count rather than force the market into a predetermined three-day pattern.
 
The Transition Between Cycles
The Sell Short Day of one cycle can also become the Buy Day of the next if the decline is deep enough and price action at the lows provides a qualifying reversal. The three-day sequence should therefore be read as a repeating market rhythm whose turning points are established by price behavior, not simply by counting calendar sessions.
 
The cycle reset. A Sell Short Day can roll into the next Buy Day when the decline creates a new low and the market shows a reversal. The reset is conditional; it is not automatic merely because the third day has ended.
Measuring Daily Price Movement
The envelope calculations translate recent price movement into projected levels for the next session. They use four interday measurements—Rally, Decline, Buying High, and Buying Under—together with a daily pivot derived from the latest completed session. 
 

For the envelope method presented here, calculate a three-session average for each of the four movement measurements. Apply those averages to the latest completed day's high or low to project the next session's levels. The daily pivot is calculated separately from that session's high, low, and close.
 
The Buy Envelope: Projected Support
The Buy Envelope contains four reference levels. Two are projected using the three-session averages; the third is the latest session's low; and the fourth is the Pivot Breakout Sell level.
 

The Decline level projects support by subtracting the average Decline Number from the latest high. The Buying Under level projects from the latest low. Buying Under can be negative when today's low is higher than yesterday's low, so retain the signed value when calculating its average.
 
The latest low provides a direct reference to the completed session. The Pivot Breakout Sell level may act as resistance; if price breaks above it, the former resistance may become support. 
 
The Sell Envelope: Projected Resistance
The Sell Envelope also contains four reference levels. Two are projected using the three-session averages; the third is the latest session's high; and the fourth is the Pivot Breakout Buy level. 
 

The Rally level adds the average Rally Number to the latest low. The Buying High level adds the average Buying High to the latest high. The latest high provides a direct reference to the completed session. The Pivot Breakout Buy level may act as support; if price breaks below it, the former support may become resistance.
 
 
These are price references, not standalone trade signals. Their significance depends on how price behaves as it approaches or crosses them.
 
Combining the Envelopes and Additional Price References
Together, the Buy and Sell Envelopes define a projected support-and-resistance framework for the next trading session. The lower envelope identifies areas where support may develop; the upper envelope identifies areas where resistance may emerge. The distance between the two gives a projected trading range based on the preceding three sessions' measured price movements.
 
Other price-reference techniques can be plotted alongside the envelopes to identify potential confluence. They should remain clearly identified as supplementary methods rather than being presented as components of Taylor's original three-day cycle. 
 

Practical Interpretation
The framework combines market timing with price projection. Taylor's cycle supplies context for anticipating likely buying and selling phases; the envelopes translate recent price movement into specific support and resistance references; and supplementary pivot methods can show whether independent calculations cluster around the same prices.
 
Confluence can make a price area more worthy of attention, but it does not guarantee a reversal. Evaluate the market's response at the level: does price reject it, accept it, break through it, or fail to follow through? The calculations are made after the session closes, using completed daily OHLC data, and are projected onto the next trading session.
 
The central principle is to anticipate the market's rhythm, map its likely trading boundaries, and judge the quality of an opportunity by the way price behaves at those levels.
 
 Toby Crabel's Daily Taylor Levels. 
 
Reference:
 
» There are only two ways a short-term high or low is broken. « 

Saturday, November 14, 2026

Live S&P 500 (ES) 5-Minute Opening Range Breakout

Carlo Zarattini identified the 5-Minute Opening Range Breakout (ORB) as the most profitable S&P 500 (ES) ORB strategy, using the 9:30–9:35 a.m. ET opening range. A 5-minute live chart in the right column of the blog shows a single ES session, from 7:15 a.m. to 7:15 p.m. ET, represented by 144 five-minute bars. A live ES feed adds each new bar from left to right within this fixed window. The window remains in place until 7:15 a.m. ET on the next trading day, when a new one opens. The footer identifies the next update. Moving the vertical grey dashed slider across the chart reveals the exact time, while the data line below the chart's title displays each bar's OHLC values.

Daily Bread & Butter Scalping and Short-Term Trading Setups.

Blue shading covers the period before 9:30 a.m. ET and from 4:15 p.m. ET onward. The prior session's opening range, midpoint, and targets extend across the morning shade and stop at 9:30. A blue 20-bar EMA follows the bars and restarts at 9:30. Zarattini's 5-Minute Opening Range Breakout trades the 9:30–9:35 bar. A close below that bar's range signals a short, which remains in effect even if price later breaks above the range. A close above that bar's range signals a long, which remains in effect even if price later breaks below the range. A 9:35 a.m. close equal to the 9:30 a.m. open is a doji and generates no trade setup.

Entry is a buy stop at a bullish 5-minute bar's high or a sell stop at a bearish bar's low, plus or minus your broker's bid-ask spread. The ORB band remains grey until that level is reached, then turns greenish above the high or reddish below the low, with the color remaining unchanged thereafter. The green numbers above the high and red numbers below the low represent profit targets, each set at a further multiple of half the opening range; the number therefore indicates the reward in those units.
 
Zarattini’s stop is set at 10% of the daily ATR (14) from the entry price (blue dashed horizontal SL line), as indicated by the blue bold figure in the bottom-left corner. Evaluate whether this automatically generated stop level is appropriately positioned relative to nearby imbalances (FVGs) and liquidity levels (previous swing highs and lows on the 5-minute chart), and adjust it if necessary. If the stop is not hit, the trade exits at 4:00 p.m. ET. The reward at the selected target, divided by the stop-loss distance, determines the risk/reward ratio (R), with approximately 1% of equity at risk per trade. Aim for a risk/reward ratio of at least 2R.


 
The 4:00 p.m. exit follows Larry Williams’ day-trading advice, HTTC (Hold to the Close). A short scalping clock often misses the larger trend, while the wide-range days that make this setup more profitable often finish at their extremes, allowing the trade to run. Zarattini's 5-minute ORB strategy may perform even better when combined with a straightforward daily directional bias concept, traded exclusively after Crabel narrow-range days (ideally NR7 or IDnr4), and aligned with hourly liquidity ranges and key levels. Entries may also be refined using ICT entry models and time macros (yes, ICT's videos can be wordy and lengthy, but all of them contain gems. Also, check out JadeCap in the blog's right column).
 
 

Tuesday, October 27, 2026

Double Inside Day, What's Next: Wider Bar, One Side

A Double Inside Day is two Inside Days (ID) in a row. The second bar sits inside the first, and the first sits inside the bar before it. That outer bar is the mother. The second day is inside the mother too. The question is the next session.
 
 
 Dow (YM), Oct 27, 2026, NR7, ID, IDnr4, 2BNR, Double Inside Day (gold-colored bars)—its narrowest range in 11 sessions:
The October 28 setup offers no directional bias for the breakout. However, the YM breaks to one side 90% of the time
and prints an Outside Day (OD) only 10% of the time—in other words, just once since 2020.

In the Crabel Pattern Scanner database (January 1, 2020 to date) are 250 of them, 0.7% of these sessions. Futures had 79. FX had 171. The E-mini S&P printed 5. The Mini Dow (YM) printed 10. Another is open now and is not in the count: October 27 sits inside October 26, and October 26 sits inside the October 23 Outside Day (OD).

The Next Bar Is Wider. And it is usually not an Outside Day (OD): The next range was wider on 79.2% of them, against 49.0% on any day. The median was 1.48 times the second Inside Day (ID). Futures were wider 63 times in 79, median 1.58. FX was wider 78.9% of the time, median 1.44. A third Inside Day (ID) came 5.2% of the time, against a 12.6% base, and on 5.1% of the futures cases. An Outside Day (OD) came 17.6% of the time, and 10.1% on the futures, which is under the 11.2% futures base. The break is one side of the second Inside Day (ID): 77.2% overall, 84.8% on the futures. 

Read the green names as the same result on more days, not as a separate system. The rose name failed to expand: USD/CAD, 50% of 8. A cell with fewer than four cases is left plain. None of these names are that small.

Six instruments never printed an Outside Day (OD) after a Double Inside Day: the E-mini S&P (ES), Nasdaq (NQ), Crude (CL), the Canadian Dollar (USD/CAD), the Kiwi (NZD/USD), and the Rand (USD/ZAR). Crude, 9 of 9, and the Kiwi, 7 of 7, left through one side every time. The other four each stayed inside once.
One Side Breaks: The pattern does not say which. High only and low only split 92 against 101. The next close was up 51.2% of the time, against 51.3% on any day. There is no side in the pattern. The side is decided by the next open, not by the two Inside Days (ID). Of the one-sided breaks, the close finished beyond the broken extreme 45.6% of the time. The rest came back inside. Futures held it 47 of 67. Across all 21 that is not a rule. The direction is not either. The mother bar was tagged, high or low, on 58.8% of the next sessions, and the close finished beyond it on 16.0%. Do not require the outer bar to give way the same day. The trade is the break of the second Inside Day (ID). The Mini Dow's (YM) ten completed cases were wider nine times. 

Green marks a close that held the one-sided break: the E-mini S&P (ES), Nasdaq (NQ), Bitcoin (BTC), and Gold (GC). Rose marks a close that came back inside, which is most of the FX pairs, or a next close that was up on 40% of the days or fewer: Sterling (GBP/USD), the Aussie (AUD/USD), and the Mexican Peso (USD/MXN). Use the green as the hold. Do not trade the rose as a side.
The Day Itself 
The second Inside Day (ID) is the tight end of the coil. Its range is a median 0.68 of the first Inside Day (ID) and 0.43 of the mother. It is also an NR4 on 84.8% of these days, and on 92.4% of the futures cases. The mother was itself an Outside Day (OD) 20.0% of the time, and 19.0% of the time on the futures. That is the sequence on the Dow (YM) this week. An Outside Day (OD), then two Inside Days (ID). The contraction is real. It is also rare. An ordinary Inside Day (ID) is a much more common pause. This is the pause that got smaller again.
 
 The Next Session
The next range was wider on 79.2% of the 250, against 49.0% on any day. The median was 1.48 times the second Inside Day (ID). Futures were wider 63 times in 79, a median 1.58. FX was wider 78.9% of the time, a median 1.44. A third Inside Day (ID) came 5.2% of the time, against a 12.6% base, and on 5.1% of the 79 futures cases.
 
The break was one side of the second Inside Day (ID) on 77.2% of sessions, and on 84.8% of the futures. An Outside Day (OD) came 17.6% of the time, and 10.1% on the futures, which is under the 11.2% futures base. Do not wait for the next bar to engulf. The expansion leaves through one side.
 
 
P.S. (Oct. 29): And here is how this Double Inside Day in the YM on Oct 26-27 played out: two consecutive Outside Days (ODs, blue) on Oct. 28–29, and both ODs still within the Oct. 23 OD mother bar—a sequence with no prior precedent in the six-year pattern database. A very unusual range pattern. Portfolio rebalancing and distribution are taking place around Q4 and October pivot point levels. Meanwhile, seasonality, the geomagnetic Ap Index, Jack Gillen's Moon-in-Virgo–Pisces NYSE/YM trading bias, a sensitive degree of the Sun, and the October 29 downside CHoCH in the YM converge to signal a low in the YM and US stock indices around Tuesday, Nov. 3.

Saturday, October 24, 2026

The 5-Minute Opening Range Breakout (ORB) Strategy | Carlo Zarattini et al.

A popular day-trading strategy is the n-minute Opening Range Breakout (ORB), with 5-, 15-, 30-, and 60-minute variants. It defines the Opening Range by the high and low of the first n-minutes, then enters a trade when price breaks above or below that range.
 
5-Minute ORB Long and Short Entry Levels.
 
Zarattini et al. identify the 5-minute ORB as the most profitable S&P 500 strategy, using the 9:30–9:35 a.m. ET Opening Range:
►Bearish Opening Bar: Go short if it closes below its open; hold even if price breaks above the Opening Range.
►Bullish Opening Bar: Go long if it closes above its open; hold even if price breaks below the Opening Range.
►Doji Bar: No trade if the close equals the open. 

Equity curves for S&P 500 buy-and-hold (red) versus long/short ORB trading using 5-, 15-, 30-, and 60-minute ranges. COMBO (black) is equally weighted across all four. Period: 2016–2023; initial capital: $25,000; commission: $0.0035 per share. 

S&P 500 buy-and-hold vs. long/short day trading the 5-, 15-, 30-, and 60-minute ORBs. COMBO is equally weighted across all four. Period: 2016–2023; initial capital: $25,000; commission: $0.0035 per share. 
►Entry: Buy-stop at a bullish bar's high; sell-stop at a bearish bar's low.
►Stop Loss and Exit: Stop at 10% of ATR from entry; otherwise, exit at 4:00 p.m. ET.
►Position Sizing: Risk approximately 1% of account equity per trade.
►Performance: Outperforms longer ORB time frames and buy-and-hold. 
 Reference:

 » My Day Trade Secret: HTTC — Hold To The Close.
 « 

Thursday, October 22, 2026

Wide Spread 7, What's Next: Smaller Range, No Follow-Through

A Wide Spread 7 (WS7) occurs when a session's high-to-low range is the widest of the past seven sessions. In Toby Crabel's framework, narrow days signal contraction and wide days signal expansion. Traders typically use the narrow day as a setup for a trade at the next open. This study reverses the question: what happens after a WS7, and is the wide day itself tradable?

 WS7 (gold-colored bars) in Natural Gas (NG). Oct 21, 2026: Widest range in 19 trading days. 
 
It addresses four questions: how wide a WS7 is, in both range and closing position; whether it breaks out of a narrow day; what happens in the following session across 21 instruments (7 futures and 14 FX pairs, October 2024 to date); and how long runs of wide days persist. The main finding is that the next session has a smaller range roughly five times in six, while its close does not follow the wide day’s direction. WS7s are not rare: they occur in 14.4% of sessions, or about one in seven, roughly the rate expected if ranges were randomly shuffled. The WS7 itself is not an unusual signal. The recurring contraction that follows is the more significant finding.
 
WS7 (gold-colored bars) in the Mexican Peso (USD/MXN). Oct 21, 2026: Widest range in 8 trading days.

The Day Itself
A WS7 is a large day and an ordinary kind of large. The median is 1.71 times the day before it, 1.59 times the average true range of the previous fourteen sessions, and 1.53% of the price. A WS4 that never becomes a WS7 is milder, 1.41 times the prior day and barely over its recent average range. The WS7 is the widest session in a median of fourteen days. Two in three are the widest in twenty sessions or fewer. One in eight is the widest in more than sixty, and that tail is the climax, not the typical bar.
 
How Big a WS7 Is: Range against the prior day, against ATR(14), and against the Close.
The WS4 row includes the WS7 days.
 
Up and down split evenly. The up day closes a median of +0.91%. The down day closes a median of −0.96%. The next session's average close is −0.04% after the up day and +0.10% after the down day. The range gives way. The price barely moves. The median giveback of the wide day's close-to-close thrust is 8% of that thrust, because the next day is too small to give the move back and too aimless to extend it.
Where It Comes From
The cycle is the useful part, and it runs in one direction. A tight day is followed by a larger day. A wide day is followed by a smaller one. That is Crabel's Contraction/Expansion Principle, the same cycle Larry Williams calls the Natural Cycle of Range Change.

 Small Range, Then What: Same 21 markets and the same sessions.
 Green: the next range is larger at least 80% of the time. Rose: the expansion has already printed.

An NR7 is followed by a larger range 82.8% of the time, at 1.46 times the narrow day. An IDnr4 is next, 81.4% and 1.44 times. An NR4 is 76.3% and 1.34 times. An ordinary day is a coin flip, 0.99 times yesterday. Futures, the majors, and the volatile pairs give the same ratios. The strongest cell is an IDnr4 on the futures: larger the next day 85% of the time, 1.48 times, on 254 sessions. Connors and Raschke built the inside-day (ID) and NR4 trade on that same fact: the coil is the setup, and the break is the next session.
 
That larger day is not, as a rule, a WS7. The session after an NR4 is a WS4 on 25.1% of days. The base rate is 24.8%. The session after an NR7 is a WS7 on 12.7% of days, against 14.4% on any day. The expansion is real, and it is modest. It is bigger than the coil. It is not the widest week of the month, and the coil does not make that outcome more likely. The definitions used here are his: a WS4 is the unique widest of four sessions, a WS7 the unique widest of seven, the mirror of NR4 and NR7.
 
So the setup is the day before. The WS7 is the result. Only about half of WS4 days were even preceded by an NR, an NR4, or an inside day (ID), which is how often those bars occur anyway. A wide day is not the signature of an IDnr4 breaking. It is just a wide day.
 
The Next Session
The session after a WS7 is narrower 83.9% of the time, and that range is 0.65 of the spike. Crude Oil does it on 90.9% of its 66 cases. The Yen (USD/JPY), the Swedish Krona (USD/SEK), and the Norwegian Krone (USD/NOK) do it on about 88%. Nasdaq keeps its range the most and is still narrower 77% of the time. Another WS4 the next day is slightly less common than on an ordinary day, 21.5% against 24.8%. A second outside day (OD) falls to 3% from an 11% base. The expansion does not immediately engulf again.
 
Green: next range narrower 85% or more, or the close continues 55% or more.
Rose: the close continues 40% or less.
 
The close is the part that tempts a trade, and it does not pay. The next close follows the WS7 only 46.2% of the time. Two WS7 days in three finish in the outer quarter of their range. Those follow through 45.1% of the time. A close on the extreme is not a reason to hold.
 
The green cells on the right of that table are the exceptions, and they are small. Crude's up-close continued on 70% of 30 days. Bitcoin's down-close continued on 62% of 37, and the Swedish Krona's on 65% of 34. The Yen failed in both directions, 38% and 30%. Natural Gas printed the largest average up-close in the set, +6.86%, and the next session still went with it less than half the time. Same range cycle. Different next close. None of those cells is large enough to become a system.
 
An inside day (ID) does show up more often the next session, 28% after a WS7 against a 14% base. Part of that is arithmetic. A wide bar is an easy container to trade inside. It is still the contraction shape that becomes more common. An NR4 the next morning does not. It stays near its ordinary one-in-four rate, and when it does appear the spike is still inside its four-day window, so "narrowest of four" is easy. That is not yet a fresh coil.
 
Gold (GC), Oct 22, 2026, following NR7 and 4BNR on Oct 21 (gold-colored bars)—its narrowest range in 192 sessions: Before noon, GC had already transitioned into a WS7. Williams' Natural Cycle of Range Change in action. What’s next? A tighter range? A reversal up? A continuation down? An inside day (ID)? No prediction. No guessing. No rushing. Patience pays. No pattern, no trade. Today's pattern sets up tomorrow’s trade. The system is the order. Strategy is when to use it and how to manage it once on.
When a WS7 Streaks
A streak here means consecutive sessions that are each a WS7. The chance of another one does not grow as the run gets longer, and it does not shrink until the sample runs out. A second WS7 arrives 16.2% of the time. A third, 2.6%. A fourth, 0.46%. A random day is a WS7 14.4% of the time, so the label has almost no memory. About five of these days in six are the end of the run. Once one has printed, the expected extra length is 0.2 sessions.
 
When a WS7 keeps coming: The chance of another WS7 does not rise as the run gets longer.
 
Four in a row happened six times in two years, across all 21 markets. Five never did. The session after the fourth day was narrower than that fourth day in every case. In five of the six, the next five sessions all stayed under it. Nasdaq, in the first week of November 2025, is the one that made a new high range later that week. None of the six was a four-day trend. The close flips inside the run. Gold and the New Zealand Dollar against the Yen (NZD/JPY) rose for two sessions and fell for two, while the range kept making highs. The expansion is in the range. The fourth day is where it stops.
 
What to Do with All This
An NR7 or an IDnr4 says the next range expands against the coil about five times in six. That is the session to work. If today has already printed the WS7, the expansion you were waiting for has been spent. Do not arm another breakout because the range was wide. Expect something near two-thirds of that range on the next session. Stand aside, or switch to another instrument with a Triple-A+ setup.
 

Do not chase the close. Direction is a coin flip, slightly against the wide day, on futures and on FX together. Do not fade the whole move either. The next session only walks back a small fraction of it. Crude's up-day is the one continuation worth a look, and it is thirty days. The Yen is the close that fails most often. Neither changes the rule for the other nineteen markets. If a second WS7 prints, you are in the 16%. Take something off if you are still long or short from the coil. A third is one start in forty. A fourth is a list of six, and the next session contracted in all six. There was no fifth in this study window to wait for.
 
The next setup is the next real contraction, once the spike has left the lookback. An inside day (ID) the next morning is a pause inside a wide bar, not automatically a new NR4. A fresh NR4 or IDnr4 after that spike has dropped out of the window is the coil again. Then the cycle applies, and the trade is that next session, not the wide one you just had.
 
 
 
  Crabel Pattern Occurrence Stats for 7 Futures and 14 FX pairs, October 2024 to date.
 
[ This Little Crabel Pattern Quartet is for those asking, "You actually trade Astro, Space Weather,
Gann, Bayer, Cycles, Hurst?" No. Fascinating, but no edge. Systematic Trading is the real deal.
I use an Excel spreadsheet to scan Crabel patterns, which I made public last week. ]