The Curse of Democracy | Russell Geoffrey Banks

How true it was when Plato said, "Democracy does not choose the best leader; it chooses the best liar." And this is why every single democracy fails eventually. Democracy does not reward wisdom; it rewards persuasion. The one who understands reality loses to the one who can manipulate perception. The honest lose to the charming. The dedicated lose to the theatrical. Plato said the heaviest penalty for decline in power was to be ruled by someone inferior.

 

 

 » Tyranny naturally arises out of democracy, and the most aggravated

form of tyranny and slavery out of the most extreme liberty. « 

Plato, The Republic, Book VIII, around 375 BC.

 

And that was not moral advice; that was the law of power. When competence withdraws, manipulation advances. When truth is costly, lies become efficient. And when popularity decides authority, deception is always the strategy. Democracy does not collapse from the outside. It hollows itself from within, and when the lies finally shake the system, the ending is predictable. The people don't resist tyranny; they beg for it. That's how bad things have to get: they beg for it.

The Spiritual Roots of Baltasar Gracián's Worldly Wisdom | Hei Sing Tso

Baltasar Gracián's book "The Art of Worldly Wisdom" (1647) is widely read and praised all over the world. Many people compare it to Machiavelli's "Prince" and Sun Tzu's "Art of War." Most think that this is a wisdom manual for secular success in career, politics, and business. This is totally misconceived.

 

 »  Keep hope alive without entirely satisfying it. «

Baltasar Gracián y Morales S.J. (1601-1658).

Gracián was a Catholic Jesuit and philosopher. Faith and theology are still at the center of his inner world. On the other hand, Jesuits were different from other Catholic orders. They aim to engage with the secular world. Educated in Thomistic and Aristotelian ethics, it is logical for Gracián to bridge worldliness and the divine. His ethics are known as the philosophy of Ingenium, while the virtue of prudence is a form of Ingenium. Through the practice of prudence in worldly affairs, one can attain salvation after death. Prudence is a channel linking the world and the holy divine. 

 

Hence, I view that the English title for the book is misleading. The original Spanish title of the book is "Oráculo Manual y Arte de Prudencia" (The Pocket Oracle and the Art of Prudence). Prudencia is the virtue of prudence. Gracián aims to encourage people to practice prudence in the world for achieving access to the divine by reading this little manual in daily life. This is a spiritual action treatise, not a self-help book for worldly success in the common understanding. 

 

»  Intellect is not enough; character is also needed. «

Although the book consists of short maxims, one should read these between the lines with contemplation. We can use the Chinese wisdom approach of "微言大义" (trivial words with great ideas) in reading Gracián's book, finding out hidden and deeper wisdom for life in parallel with spirituality.

The First Maxim

Everything is at its peak of perfection. This is especially true of the art of making one’s way in the world. There is more required nowadays to make a single wise person than formerly to make the Seven Sages of ancient Greece, and more is needed nowadays to deal with a single person than was required with a whole people in former times.

The first maxim is very essential. This lays the foundation and the core idea of prudence in practice. Gracián thinks that every person can be on the way to perfection to access God, and this way is through practice in the secular world, not in deserts or monasteries. To be wise and access perfection, a secular person needs to practice his inner mind like the sages in ancient Greece. However, this is more difficult in the secular world, as he is easily addicted to evil temptations. The last sentence has political implications. Firstly, a prudent statesman can lead a nation to win any war, even if the enemy has more resources. Secondly, if the leader of your enemy lacks prudence, we can take this weakness as a strategic opportunity.

The Second Maxim

Character and intellect. These are the two poles of our capacity: one without the other is but halfway to happiness. Intellect is not enough; character is also needed. On the other hand, it is the fool’s misfortune to fail in obtaining the position, employment, neighbour, and circle of friends of his choice.

This is the first wisdom to build up a capacity for prudence. Most people value intellect highly, as this can be objectively tested and evaluated. We attend the same lessons and got similar MBAs. However, Gracián taught us to know our character first. God makes every person unique. Sun Tzu said, "You will win every time when you know yourself and your enemy fully!" Further, character should match close surroundings, because employment, neighbors, and circle of friends are your personal strategic assets. The more you know your character, the more prudent you are.

The Third Maxim

Keep matter for a time in suspense. Admiration at their novelty heightens the value of your achievements. It is both useless and insipid to play with your cards on the table. If you do not declare yourself immediately, you arouse expectation, especially when the importance of your position makes you the object of general attention. Mix a little mystery with everything, and the very mystery arouses veneration. And when you explain, do not be too explicit, just as you do not expose your inmost thoughts in ordinary conversation. Cautious silence is the sacred sanctuary of worldly wisdom. A resolution declared is never highly thought of—it only leaves room for criticism. And if it happens to fail, you are doubly unfortunate. Besides, you imitate the divine way when you inspire people to wonder and watch.

God is mysterious, and we should learn from God. According to Lao Tzu, we should keep quietness and silence to follow the Tao. Likewise, Gracián told us to close our mouths in open settings for two strategic aims. One is to arouse expectations among supporters, and another is to avoid attacks from enemies. The last sentence clearly teaches us to imitate God to create wonder and inspiration. These are also essential for public engagement and even in election campaigns.

The Fourth Maxim

Knowledge and courage. These are the elements of greatness. Because they are immortal, they bestow immortality. Each is as much as he knows, and the wise can do anything. A person without knowledge is in a world without light. Wisdom and strength are the eyes and hands. Knowledge without courage is sterile.

When one makes prudent decisions, knowledge is necessary. However, not all knowledge is good. We should only acquire knowledge that sheds divine light for immortality and salvation. As a virtue, we need to use good knowledge with courage and persistence, even when facing difficulty, denial, and criticism. Education and ideology often forbid us to learn fringe knowledge. To Gracián, people will be wise when they have broad knowledge. Directed by divine wisdom, one can even apply this fringe knowledge to create effective strategies.

The Fifth Maxim

Make people depend on you. It is not he that adorns but he that adores that makes a divinity. The wise person would rather see others needing him than thanking him. To keep them on the threshold of hope is diplomatic; to trust in their gratitude is boorish. Hope has a good memory; gratitude a bad one. More is to be got from dependence than from courtesy. He that has satisfied his thirst turns his back on the well, and the orange, once squeezed, falls from the gold platter into the waste basket. When dependence disappears, good behavior goes with it, as well as respect. Let it be one of the chief lessons of experience to keep hope alive without entirely satisfying it, preserving it to make oneself always needed, even by a patron on the throne. But do not carry silence to excess, or you will go wrong; nor let another’s failing grow incurable for the sake of your own advantage.

God gives us hope. Hope is a virtue. If there is no hope, the relationship will not last long. In human affairs, hope is linked to a variety of dependence: physical, financial, political, and even emotional. Gracián taught us to use dependence skillfully. As mentioned in the fourth maxim, keeping silence can sometimes boost dependence, as others may make mistakes and come back to you for help. You can be a mysterious mentor for influence and power over that person. However, one should note the last sentence. To be prudent, your silence should not be excessive, and your interests should not lead to another’s sin. Otherwise, you will not have salvation.

 

According to Gracián, stratagems do not only concern the secular world. When reading these maxims with a spiritual lens, true wisdom for life will be revealed.

 

Reference:

Hei Sing Tso (April 19, 2026) - Spiritual Roots of Baltasar Gracian's Wisdom.

 

 无为 

Hei Sing Tso (曹希聖) is a Hong Kong–based lawyer, independent scholar, and geopolitical commentator. Trained in law at the City University of Hong Kong and the University of Edinburgh, he also holds a Master's degree in Theology from the University of Chester. His work focuses on the intersection of Chinese strategic thought, philosophy, and international relations, with particular emphasis on classical traditions such as Sun Tzu, Guiguzi, and the I Ching. He is the president of Guiguzi Stratagem Learning and the author of I Ching and 36 Tricks.

See also:

Hei Sing Tso (2023) - Stratagems in China's Diplomacy and Defense Policy.

Waiting for the Axe of History to Fall | Constantin von Hoffmeister

Aristotle, the ancient diagnostician of democracy, looms over this spectacle like an unblinking oracle. He saw this coming over two thousand years ago. In Politics, he warned of democracy’s slow suicide, its descent into ochlocracy, the rule of the mob, where plebeian apathy and elite corruption conspire to suffocate the soul of the polis. And now? Germany, the heart of the European project, is gasping in its terminal stage, a civilization devouring itself in the throes of bureaucratic sterility. Aristotle’s nightmare — where democracy degenerates into oligarchic tyranny — has unfolded before our eyes, and the people, battered and betrayed, have turned to the AfD in search of salvation.

Oswald Spengler.

This is not just another election. It is an insurrection of the disillusioned, the dispossessed, the ones cast aside in the great sacrificial burning of European industry, European identity, and European will. The AfD’s 20% is more than a number. It is a hammer blow to the temple of a senile establishment that clings to power like a parasite to a dying host. Oswald Spengler, always lurking in the shadows of decline, grins from the abyss, his vision of the West’s Untergang — the inevitable sinking into civilizational night — now fully realized in the pale, hollow eyes of Merkel and Scholz’s progeny.

Germany, once a titan of industrial might, now watches its factories shuttered, its energy bills soaring to heights unknown, its streets flooded not with the march of progress but with the quiet desperation of a people abandoned. Unvetted mass immigration further strains an already collapsing system, diluting national cohesion, fueling rising crime, and deepening economic turmoil. Deindustrialization is not a policy; it is a ritual suicide, orchestrated by an elite class that sneers at the workers it claims to represent. This self-inflicted ruin stems from the foolish decision to sever Russian oil and gas supplies while simultaneously shutting down perfectly safe and clean nuclear power plants, triggered by green hysteria, leaving the nation energy-starved and vulnerable. The AfD’s rise is the backlash, the return of the repressed, the last, desperate howl of a nation refusing to kneel before its executioners.

 » Deindustrialization is not a policy; it is a ritual suicide. «

And yet, even as the AfD ascends, the rot remains. 20% is not enough. Not yet. The CDU, ever the shapeshifting chameleon of power, will twist itself into whatever grotesque coalition is required to keep the machine grinding on. The system is designed to perpetuate itself, to stifle true revolution before it can take root. Aristotle knew this, too — democracy’s end does not come with a sudden coup but with a slow, meticulous suffocation, the masses lulled into a stupor while the oligarchs tighten their grip.

Europe, as a geopolitical force, is vanishing. The great capitals — Berlin, Paris, London — are husks, their relevance bleeding away with every year that passes, every decision made to weaken their own people. Power is shifting, tectonic, and irreversible. The new centers of the West are no longer in Brussels or Strasbourg, those necropolises of decrepit bureaucracy, but in Moscow and Washington, in the hard men of Russia and the Trumpist resurgence in America, where will-to-power has not yet been extinguished.

The AfD, for all its momentum, must now decide whether it is content to be a protest vote or whether it will grasp the mantle of true revolution. Because Spengler’s twilight is here, and Aristotle’s lesson rings louder than ever: democracies do not die in flames; they decay from within, rotting until they are but incinerated ruins waiting for the axe of history to fall.

And the axe is coming.

Constantin von Hoffmeister
February 23, 2025.

 

 » I doubt whether Mr. Merz would have won without the election fraud in the country. Added to that are the
3.5 million votes from people living abroad who weren’t able to vote because the documents arrived too late! «

 

The term 'banana republic' is inappropriate to describe the 'German' regime: 

To begin with, Germany is not a sovereign state and has no constitution—just like the State of Israel in Palestine, the so-called 'Federal Republic of Germany' is merely another illegitimate occupation regime for a pitiful territory with defeated and displaced natives in it, getting settled by foreign migrants, ruled and exploited since 80 years by Anglo-US-French Zionists, their stooges, and a Basic Law. The good news is that both the State of Israel and the Federal Republic of Germany are crumbling.

 

 

» I know, Jews will be resented for their leading role. «

 Dr. Barbara Lerner Spectre, calling for the destruction of Christian European ethnic societies

by means of organized mass immigration, 2015. 

 

See also: 

Marrakesh Migration Compact, formally known as the United Nations Global Compact

 for Safe, Orderly, and Regular Migration, Morocco, December 10, 2018. 

了解你的敌人
Know your Enemies.